Horror and Racism in Lovecraft Country

Marisa Moore • November 23, 2020

Share this article

Lovecraft Country characters Leti, Tic, and George standing in a misty forest at dusk.

On August 16 of this past summer, Misha Green’s television adaptation of the novel Lovecraft Country first aired on the streaming service HBO. The show is set in 1950s Chicago and follows Atticus “Tic” Freeman, a Korean War veteran, and his childhood friend “Leti” Lewis. Tic is an avid reader of Lovecraft and other pulp fiction authors, and the show’s very first scene depicts the infamous Lovecraftian monster, Cthulhu. [SLIDE 2] Howard Phillips Lovecraft was [quote] “anti-Semitic, racist, and classist,” attitudes which ultimately shine through in his work (Sharrett 22). So why would a story put itself in context with Lovecraftian horror if Lovecraft himself was a figure of such contention? Christopher Sharrett writes, “Lovecraft, more than any other writer, gave the [horror] genre its notion of the monstrous Other” (Sharrett 23). Lovecraft Country incorporates this trope, as so many horror films, novels, and shows before it, but subverts what the “Other” has historically represented. This is most evident in the first episode of the series entitled “Sundown.” [SLIDE 3]

 

In the first episode, Tic, Leti, and Tic’s uncle, George Freeman, travel to Ardham, Massachusetts to look for his missing father, Montrose, who wrote Tic about his [quote] “secret legacy, a birthright that’s been kept from [him]” in Arkham, Massachusetts (“Sundown” 00:13:15-00:13:20). Tic shows the letter to George who identifies the fictional Lovecraftian town of “Arkham” as the real town of Ardham, known only now as Devon County (“Sundown” 00:24:00-00:24:10). [SLIDE 4] When the three arrive at a town called Simmonsville, just outside Devon County, they are met with hostility and racism from the white people living there, chased by another car out of town under gunfire (“Sundown” 00:37:06).

 

During the chase, a third car appears and manages to flip the assailant's vehicle as if by magic. A white woman exits from the third car, unhurt, and looks at Tic with significance. We are introduced at this point to Christina Braithwhite (“Sundown” 00:38:19-00:39:10). Christina is an interesting character and establishes for the show that magic is power. This is not touched on in the first episode, which I will be primarily discussing today, but she is arguably the most important white character to the story and is actually the one who wrote and sent Tic a letter about his supposed great legacy, that is, his connection to her family and to magic.

 

After escaping, the three make it to Leti’s brother’s home nearby where he tells them of weird stories surrounding Bideford, a city in Devon County, claiming it to be founded centuries ago by witch-hunters who [quote] “don’t like outsiders at all” (“Sundown” 00:40:00-00:40:26). He also warns them of the violent and racist Sheriff Eustice Hunt who patrols there. While the three are driving through Devon County, looking for an overgrown road that supposedly leads to Ardham, they are pulled over by this very sheriff who asks, “Any of you all know what a sundown town is?...,Well, this is a sundown county” (“Sundown” 00:50:30-00:50:38). Sheriff Hunt threatens them with hanging if they do not leave by nightfall, giving the trio only a few minutes to escape.

 

They barely make it out in time only to be stopped by more officers that Sheriff Hunt had arranged as an ambush just outside the county line. The three are taken into the woods at gunpoint, but are all ambushed by Shoggoths, a Lovecraftian monster. [SLIDE 5] Shoggoths in Lovecraft Country are massive, white, wolf-like creatures with eyes covering their bodies. They infect the officers like vampires, consuming and turning the surviving ones into monsters with a bite. George quotes Dracula, “’Children of the night…what music they make,’” and explains to Leti and Tic he survived the initial attack with just a flashlight; [quote] “If I’m right, and the light hurts them, it’ll also explain why we been drivin’ in the woods all day and didn’t encounter one until the sun went down (“Sundown” 01:00:27-01:00:35). [SLIDE 6] I have included this scene, but of course, viewer warnings for gore, violence, and language. [SLIDE 7]

 

This is how Lovecraft Country first blends horror and racialized fear. Sundown towns were, and in some capacities still are, a real threat to black Americans, but Lovecraft Country illustrates that monstrous, consuming, and destructive threat by way of Lovecraft’s creations. The Shoggoths are the sheriffs that ambushed them, the white threat that appears after sundown. The goal of this paper is to argue for the reimagining of a highly consumed genre of media to both establish its role as a tool for social commentary, and as an instrument for exploring relevant social change. It will survey recent academic writing on the topic, covering black filmmaking from the 1970s Blaxploitation movie era to Jordan Peele’s Get Out (2017). In order to appreciate and analyze the significance of black horror stories, it is important to survey how black Americans have been depicted in and treated by horror films in the past. [SLIDE 8]

 

In Robin R. Means Coleman’s book, Horror Noire: Blacks in American Horror Films from the 1890s to Present, she writes, “As the 1950s emerged, Black characters were a very scarce commodity in horror” (Coleman 94). They had appeared in films for the previous fifty years, [quote] “relegated to roles such as that of the primitive, jungle native or servant to Whites” (Coleman 66). It was not until 1968 when George R. Romero’s film Night of the Living Dead first premiered that the role of black characters in horror made a turning point. Ben, played by Duane Jones, “heroically and singularly survives a relentless, night-long attack by cannibalistic ghouls only to be shot dead in the bright light of day by a posse of White vigilantes” (Coleman 104).

 

Kevin Heffernan commented on the success of this film among black audiences, as Coleman puts it: “on the whole Black film-goers represented thirty percent of first-run audiences compared to [representing] fifteen to twenty percent of the general population” (Coleman 109). This would lead to the prolific Blaxploitation film era of the 1970s. Films like Blacula (1972) and many others marked this Black horror boom wherein black characters were still the “monstrous Other,” but now the empathetic lead (Benshoff). I spoke about this topic more in depth in my short presentation from earlier this semester, but I wanted to revisit it here because I see a parallel between Night of the Living Dead and Blacula, and between Get Out and Lovecraft Country. [SLIDE 9]

 

Jordan Peele’s 2017 film Get Out was a landmark for Black horror. It grossed 255 million dollars worldwide (Box Office Mojo) and marked the first time a Black man won an Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay (Desta). It is also one of six horror films ever nominated for Best Picture (Durkan). Peele’s film would help define a renaissance of black horror, marked by films and projects such as Antebellum (2020), Us (2019), The Girl with All the Gifts (2016), and, of course, Lovecraft Country (2020). In Ryan Poll’s essay, “Can One ‘Get Out?’ The Aesthetics of Afro-Pessimism,” Peele’s film is analyzed within this theory. Afro-pessimism is an idea that, [quote] “the modern world was created by Black slavery. The world of White Masters and Black Slaves is the world we have inherited and the world we live in today” (Poll 70). This idea is represented by the continuous reconstruction of the master/slave paradigm as seen on the plantation, during Jim Crow, with the practice of redlining in the 1950s, and in the modern prisonindustrial complex. Get Out is about slavery, about modern slavery.

 

The film opens with a young black man walking at night in the suburbs. Poll writes, “In another film, in a White movie, this could be an innocuous, establishing shot. But in a movie wrestling with the United States’ legacy of race and racism, this suburban street is immediately recognizable as a site of horror for the lone Black millennial” (Poll 73). The young man’s fear is charged and palpable. Get Out comes just five years after the real-life murder of Trayvon Martin. The opening scene is complex in several ways. It plays on the stereotypical horror film opening, like that of Halloween (1978) or Scream (1996) but inverts the suburbs as a dangerous place for the “Other,” or in this case, a young black man. A white car begins to follow the young man, a masked person emerging from the car to subdue and kidnap him. Poll writes, “Peele said he wanted the car to function similarly to the great white shark from Jaws” (Poll 77). Peele is creating the white threat in this scene – whether it be the slow following shark, the 1950s sundown sheriff, the Shoggoth, or the violent exercise of racism – all within the language of a film genre historically dominated by white people. [SLIDE 10] In an interview with TV Insider, Misha Green said, “I feel like genre, when it’s at its best – it's a metaphor on top of the real world, the truth, what we’re actually experiencing” (Green 00:00:30-00:00:37). Lovecraft Country uses the horror genre to construct this metaphor over the real world, producing for the audience an experience of fear and powerlessness that only monsters, and racism can create.


Works Cited

Benshoff, Harry M. "Blaxploitation Horror Films: Generic Reappropriation or Reinscription?"

Cinema Journal, vol. 39 no. 2, 2000, p. 31-50. Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/cj.2000.0001.

Desta, Yohana. "Oscars 2018: Jordan Peele Wins an Oscar and Makes History." Vanity Fair, 5

Mar. 2018, www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2018/03/oscars-2018-jordan-peele-bestoriginal-screenplay-get-out.

Durkan, Dierdre. "'Jaws' to 'Get Out': The Only 6 Horror Films Ever Nominated for Oscar's Best

Picture." The Hollywood Reporter, 1 Mar. 2018, www.hollywoodreporter.com/lists/jawsget-6-horror-films-ever-nominated-oscars-best-picture-1088677.

"Get Out." Box Office Mojo,

www.boxofficemojo.com/release/rl256280065/rankings/?ref_=bo_rl_tab#tabs. Accessed

23 Nov. 2020.

Green, Misha. Interview with Jim Halterman. TV Insider, 21 Aug. 2020,https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecoCFpKhjc0&ab_channel=TVInsider. Accessed 28

Sept. 2020.

Means, Coleman, Robin R. Horror Noire: Blacks in American Horror Films from the 1890s to

Present, Taylor & Francis Group, 2011, pp. 198-214. ProQuest Ebook Central,

https://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/uncw/detail.action?docID=716524.

Poll, Ryan. “Can One ‘Get Out?" The Aesthetics of Afro-Pessimism.” The Journal of the

Midwest Modern Language Association, vol. 51, no. 2, 2018, pp. 69–102. JSTOR,

www.jstor.org/stable/45151156. Accessed 29 Sept. 2020.

in Popular Culture, vol. 21, no. 2, 1998, pp. 53–69. JSTOR,

Moore 7

www.jstor.org/stable/41970306. Accessed 28 Sept. 2020.

Sharrett, Christopher. “The Haunter of the Dark: H. P. Lovecraft and Modern Horror Cinema.”

Cinéaste, vol. 41, no. 1, 2015, pp. 22–26. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/26356385.

Accessed 26 Oct. 2020.

“Sundown.” Lovecraft Country, season 1, episode 1, Monkeypaw Productions, 16 August 2020.

HBO,

https://play.hbomax.com/episode/urn:hbo:episode:GXqxX5wwHskKuqwEAAASY?icid

=hbo_streamingoverlay_max&hbo_source=hbo.com&hbo_medium=referral&hbo_camp

camp=hbomax_signinlink_hbomax_button_20200701&hbo_content=62&hbo_term=hbo

_streamsignin&_ga=2.160142392.461767543.1605813704-1761460590.1605813704.

Watch my presentation:

Related Posts

A black man and woman stand before an orange sunset with looming tentacles in the background. Lovecraft Country Misha Green
By Marisa Moore February 1, 2022
In the fall of 2020, Misha Green's television adaptation of the novel Lovecraft Country aired on HBO. The show is a treat in genre storytelling, pulling together threads of horror, weird fiction, sci-fi, and the gothic into a tale about a black and white family's fight over magic. The show and novel's main character is Atticus "Tic" Freeman, a Korean War veteran and descendant of a woman who was enslaved by the white, rich, and magic-possessing Braithwhite family. However, it is the black female characters in the show who provide the most interesting and illuminating perspective on the intersection between blackness and womanhood in 1950s America. Before delving any further into the characters, we need to talk about bell hooks and what she calls the "oppositional gaze." hooks argues that white slave-owners would punish enslaved black people for looking, an attitude and stigma that has trickled through history into her own experiences.¹ She points out the danger of black men looking at white women, at the violence carried out for just a gaze. An oppositional gaze is a result and response to this stigma. "All attempts to repress our/black peoples' right to gaze had produced in us an overwhelming urge to look, a rebellious desire, an oppositional gaze,"¹ hooks writes. So, what does this have to do with Lovecraft Country? Green's show and its female characters embrace this idea of an oppositional gaze and seek to rectify the erasure of black women in media through black female representation. "When most black people in the United States first had the opportunity to look at film and television," a time closely related to the setting of Lovecraft Country, "they did so fully aware that mass media was a system of knowledge and power reproducing and maintaining white supremacy. To stare at the television, or mainstream movies, to engage its images, was to engage its negation of black representation."¹ In horror, a genre of storytelling most historically defined by its negation and (mis)representation of black people, Lovecraft Country uses its black female characters to subvert and combat the prevalence of white supremacist mass media. hooks argues that the construction of the oppositional gaze comes from a desire to resist media that devalues, objectifies, or dehumanizes black women's place in society, and reconstructs identities in resistance.¹ One of Lovecraft Country's black female filmmakers speaks about this issue of representation and characterization: "We, as Black female artists, don’t have any different depth than anybody. It’s that we don’t get the opportunity to explore the depth of our instrument. How often are writers just writing stories for us to explore and play and be imaginative and curious?" - Jurnee Smollet ("Leti Lewis") Hollywood Reporter

More Posts

Marisa Moore in graduation gown and cap near Morton Hall, UNCW campus
By Marisa Moore May 1, 2022
The most important thing I learned as an English graduate student was the value of learning to write in many different contexts. 
A Haida tribal mask burns on rocks by the seaside
By Marisa Moore March 1, 2022
By 2018, fewer than one percent of the Haida were fluent in the language. Edge of the Knife was produced during a cultural and linguistic crisis.
A black man and woman stand before an orange sunset with looming tentacles in the background. Lovecraft Country Misha Green
By Marisa Moore February 1, 2022
In the fall of 2020, Misha Green's television adaptation of the novel Lovecraft Country aired on HBO. The show is a treat in genre storytelling, pulling together threads of horror, weird fiction, sci-fi, and the gothic into a tale about a black and white family's fight over magic. The show and novel's main character is Atticus "Tic" Freeman, a Korean War veteran and descendant of a woman who was enslaved by the white, rich, and magic-possessing Braithwhite family. However, it is the black female characters in the show who provide the most interesting and illuminating perspective on the intersection between blackness and womanhood in 1950s America. Before delving any further into the characters, we need to talk about bell hooks and what she calls the "oppositional gaze." hooks argues that white slave-owners would punish enslaved black people for looking, an attitude and stigma that has trickled through history into her own experiences.¹ She points out the danger of black men looking at white women, at the violence carried out for just a gaze. An oppositional gaze is a result and response to this stigma. "All attempts to repress our/black peoples' right to gaze had produced in us an overwhelming urge to look, a rebellious desire, an oppositional gaze,"¹ hooks writes. So, what does this have to do with Lovecraft Country? Green's show and its female characters embrace this idea of an oppositional gaze and seek to rectify the erasure of black women in media through black female representation. "When most black people in the United States first had the opportunity to look at film and television," a time closely related to the setting of Lovecraft Country, "they did so fully aware that mass media was a system of knowledge and power reproducing and maintaining white supremacy. To stare at the television, or mainstream movies, to engage its images, was to engage its negation of black representation."¹ In horror, a genre of storytelling most historically defined by its negation and (mis)representation of black people, Lovecraft Country uses its black female characters to subvert and combat the prevalence of white supremacist mass media. hooks argues that the construction of the oppositional gaze comes from a desire to resist media that devalues, objectifies, or dehumanizes black women's place in society, and reconstructs identities in resistance.¹ One of Lovecraft Country's black female filmmakers speaks about this issue of representation and characterization: "We, as Black female artists, don’t have any different depth than anybody. It’s that we don’t get the opportunity to explore the depth of our instrument. How often are writers just writing stories for us to explore and play and be imaginative and curious?" - Jurnee Smollet ("Leti Lewis") Hollywood Reporter
Noir style man carrying a guitar case walking down urban street, blood and tentacles reaching
By Marisa Moore February 1, 2022
This novella attempts to reconcile the influence H.P. Lovecraft has had on the horror and science fiction genres with the harmful, racist underpinnings of his writing.
Cell phone screen with social media app icons
By Marisa Moore July 1, 2021
Before I began my graduate internship, I had no experience in digital marketing. I had to learn to write in new ways, showing me the power of an English degree.
White disposable medical mask against a blue background
By Marisa Moore December 1, 2020
My technical writing internship began during the COVID-19 pandemic. As I learned to work remotely, I also learned about collaborative work and my own work ethic.
SOMA main screen and logo
By Marisa Moore November 30, 2020
The connection between inventory/UI and identity in 'SOMA' by Frictional Games. Originally written for a graduate English class by Marisa Moore.